Although the tag looks like a Mustang tag, is it possible it is off something else? The dash pad appears to have the right shape, but it looks like it has been recovered - there is piping, or stitching, along the front edge. Mine doesn't have that, and to the best of my recollection, my previous one didn't either. Ask for a shot of the warranty tag on the door for comparison. You could also ask for a picture of the buck tag, too. Good luck!