For those of you that like the old, oe look.
Go with a cooler led. Color is denoted by Kelvins, a unit of heat measurement. 5000+ Kelvins is more pure white - ie. daylight, in the 6000s - your getting that blueish glow (the blue part of a flame is the hottest part, right?)
But in the 2500-3500 Kelvin range, I would think the color would be comparable to an incandescent bulb.
Brightness is measured in Lumens (1 Lumen = 1 candle I believe)
And Wattage? Don't worry about it, the LED will draw sooooo much less power, that's why you have equivalent wattage, at least in your home bulbs.