Jim Smith said:
Seriously, is it really better to have just a lap belt than a three point mounted below the shoulder? I'd rather risk a compressed spine than being speared thru the chest.
Why pick between two bad alternatives?
First off, Brian, thanks for posting pics of your install - there are very few willing to show how the install looks when someone is sitting with the belts buckled.
That said, IMO, the shoulder belt pivot is too low, the second picture from the side shows that while slack it is already below the 5 degree angle recommended by the sanctioning body, SFI Foundation, that sets safety specs for NASCAR, NHRA, SCCA, etc. and that are followed by Simpson, Schroth, etc. When pulled taut under load (as in a collision) it will follow the attachment points to a lower angle, putting dangerous pressure on the shoulder and spine.
Also, the female end of the lap belt portion is too long - when buckled its length positions it well into the soft tissue of the stomach, it should be shorter to keep the belt low and as close to the hips as possible.
Does anyone have these safety sheets?
Jennifer F. Bowden, SFI Foundation,
Seat Belts: Essential to Driver Safety:
"The attachment points must provide the optimum geometry to minimize movement of the belts. Lap belts perform best when they act at an angle between 45° and 55° relative to the longitudinal axis of the vehicle as illustrated in part A of the Figure.
http://www.sfifoundation.com/seatbelt.gif
This angle permits the lap belt to react to the upward pull of the shoulder harness. A system installed with a shallow belt angle, as shown in part B of the Figure, permits the shoulder harness to pull the lap belt up off the pelvic area and into the abdominal region with the likelihood of injury to internal organs.
The end attachments of the shoulder harness must also be installed at appropriate angles. The ideal position is anywhere between 5° below and 30° above the driver's shoulder, as seen in part C of the Figure.
If the upper attachment point falls significantly below the driver's shoulder, then a spinal compression injury is likely to occur. In an accident situation, the shoulder belts pull down and back on the torso as they resist the forward motion of the driver. The resultant restraint force compresses the spinal column and will add to the stresses in the spine already caused by the force of the crash impact."
See also, section 9.3.18. DRIVER’S RESTRAINT SYSTEM of the SCCA's General Competition Rules;
ARTICLE 6 : SAFETY BELTS, of the FIA WORLD TOURING CAR CHAMPIONSHIP 2007 Regulations;
the technical papers and instructions published by Schroth and Simpson, and, last but not least:
Title 49, Code of Federal Regulations: Transportation
PART 571—FEDERAL MOTOR VEHICLE SAFETY STANDARDS
§ 571.209 Standard No. 209; Seat belt assemblies.
§ 571.210 Standard No. 210; Seat belt assembly anchorages.