There is no reasonable price. At least half a dozen "classic car dealers" will buy it, and put it out there for $5000 - $10000 more than they just bought it for.
Why? Because they can.
Next thing: No comparison to a 67 or 68 GT 350. The 67 gets more as it was the last year for the highly desirable K code 289 Hi-Po

 

Theres a gt350 listed for 59K. What is a reasonable price to expect to pay for a gt350 in decent condition (1967 or 68)?

Prices are way up, however you can expect to pay at least a 15-20 thousand premium for a '67 GT350 over a 68 (excluding 68 GT350 verts of course). I have seen '67 GT350's sell between 65 and 75 thousand and FB '68 GT350's sell recently for 45-55 thousand. Any decent Shelby under $50K is a rarity these days. Make sure to do your homework and order a SAAC registry if you haven't already to check the history of any potential car. Good luck with your search.

 

well a 68 gt350 just sold off of this sight for what $46k? $60k for a nice car (68) is sounding fair to okay of course. $59k for almost any nice looking 67 driver is a steal. Problem is most people who have them know if they sell, they can't replace. So my as well go for the sky. Good luck. A good rule would be if you want it, need it and have the $$; go for it. Tony

 

The prices of the cars has gone through the roof...take a look at a couple of these junk heaps, and the price tags that they are asking....I'm not sure if they charge extra for the forklift to load on the flatbed for the ride home....unreal

http://www.coloradomustang.com/4sale/65fbredbos.html
http://www.coloradomustang.com/4sale/64-5blucvt.html