What would be reasonable to expect for miles per gallon for a 289 bored 0.040 over and a somewhat aggressive cam?
I've been driving pretty aggressively but not sure I'm breaking 11-12......."
First your cam is not mpg friendly, secondly, by your own description neither is your driving style. If your are breaking into the double digits, no matter how low, then you have no reason to expect more miles per gallon.
With a stock cam, and driving like there is an unbroken egg on top of the gas pedal, we are fortunate to get above 20 mpg.witth a 50 year old carb'd engine regardless of the rear gearing or transmission. I got 24 mpg once on a long trip and that was a miracle.
Contributing factors:
1) elvation from 4,500 to 9,000' above sea level = thin air & less air resistance.
2) supercharger and carb tuned for very very lean running at low rpm / cruising with an air/fuel meter.
3) 3.00:1 gearing
4)) no traffic
5) more air pressure than normal in tires
Driving the same car "normally" my usual mpg was in the mid to high teens.
OK, I got 18+ in both Pennsylvania and Florida with a 289HP (with 3-2V carbs), wide ratio 4 speed, 3.00:1 rear. The A code 4V I had before that got 21mpg on the highway.
This mirrors my experiences nearly exactly.
Z